Latest News

‘Buy America’ Fight Hides Harper’s Job-Policy Failures – Ken Neumann Op-Ed

February 10, 2015

The following op-ed column by USW National Director Ken Neumann has been published in the Vancouver Province:

Rather than leading the charge to defend Canadian workers and communities, Stephen Harper’s Conservatives have launched a phony war against the use of American steel for an Alaskan ferry terminal in Prince Rupert.

The Conservatives’ tough talk is little more than election-year posturing from a government that has simply stood by as hundreds of thousands of Canadians have lost good manufacturing jobs in recent years.

The Conservatives have been put on the spot by the controversy surrounding Alaska’s plan to build a new ferry terminal to replace its old facility in Prince Rupert. The terminal is located on Canadian soil, but is Alaskan-owned and operated as part of the state’s marine highway system.

An uproar ensued when Canadians learned the Alaskan government planned to apply ‘Buy America’ provisions to its new terminal. Those rules would require the use of American steel to build the $15-million facility.

Lacking a proactive strategy to promote domestic manufacturing and the good jobs that come with it, the Harper government had to devise a response to distract Canadians from its dismal record.

The Conservatives threatened to invoke a little-known federal law to prevent bidders on the new ferry terminal, prompting the Alaskan government to indefinitely suspend the project.

What has been left unsaid by the Conservatives is that, even if the ‘Buy America’ stipulation is removed from the terminal project, they won’t be helping or advocating for Canadian steel mills and workers to obtain the contract.

In fact, the Conservatives’ record indicates they would stand by and welcome a foreign offshore supplier to provide steel for the project.

After all, the Harper government has allowed many public infrastructure projects to use imported steel, often from foreign producers that enjoy overwhelmingly unfair advantages such as state subsidies, currency manipulation and atrocious environmental and labour standards.

For example, Transport Canada is currently building a new Champlain Bridge in Montreal – a $5-billion project – without making any effort to use Canadian steel. To place it in perspective, the Champlain Bridge project is more than 300 times larger than the Prince Rupert terminal.

Rather than tilting at ‘Buy America’ on a small ferry terminal, a federal government serious about supporting Canadian jobs would apply some form of ‘Buy Canada’ provisions to multibillion-dollar, publicly funded infrastructure projects across the country.

The Harper Conservatives also have failed Canadians by refusing to pursue a ‘Buy North America” policy for stimulus spending programs launched in the wake of the 2008 economic crisis.

The United Steelworkers has long advocated for such a binational approach to support North American manufacturing on both sides of the border.

Such a policy is realistic and desirable for both countries, given that North American manufacturing is highly integrated, with component parts crossing the Canada-U.S. border throughout the production process. A Buy North America approach would allow companies with cross-border supply chains to fully exploit the advantages of this integration, increasing demand for Canadian-made and American-made products.

Canada’s steel industry has been beset by massive trade imbalances over the last decade. This has been due almost entirely to trade deficits with offshore producers like China, averaging $3 billion to $4 billion annually. In contrast, when it comes to our steel trade with the U.S., Canada has had as many annual surpluses as deficits in the same period.

If Harper were serious about standing up for Canadian workers, he would seek to negotiate with the U.S. on reciprocal access to public procurement of steel while favouring North American production over offshore imports. However, our Conservative government has flatly rejected such solutions, preferring to adhere to its ideology while hundreds of thousands of Canadians have lost good jobs.

View op-ed in Vancouver Province

Join our newsletter

Recent news

Featured image for What is Ottawa waiting for, before it takes stronger action against steel dumping?

What is Ottawa waiting for, before it takes stronger action against steel dumping?

November 6, 2026 | Media Releases

Layoffs coming at Nova Tube, more uncertainty in the steel sector MONTREAL – The United Steelworkers union (USW) is publicly asking how many more jobs must be lost, or steel plants closed, before the federal government takes stronger action to crack down on unfair trade that is harming Canada’s steel industry. The USW has learned […]

Highland Valley Copper Hot Edict

BCFED issues hot edict in USW strike at Highland Valley Copper operation

November 6, 2026 | Media Releases

USW District 3 welcomes the BC Federation of Labour’s declaration of a hot edict on mineral products and by-products from Teck’s Highland Valley Copper operation. This is a powerful show of solidarity with more than 1,200 members of USW Local 7619 who have been on strike since October 24, fighting for fair wages, pensions, adequate […]

Image for Budget makes progress, but more work must be done: Steelworkers

Budget makes progress, but more work must be done: Steelworkers

November 5, 2026 | Statements

TORONTO – The United Steelworkers union (USW) issued the following statement in response to the federal budget 2026: “The United Steelworkers welcomes federal investments in Canada’s forestry and wood products sector, as well as in the critical minerals industry. These are important steps toward the industrial strategy Canada needs. But we cannot build the industries […]