Omnibus Bill Needs Rewrite
Blacklocks Reporter – Cabinet must rewrite labour amendments after the Supreme Court struck down a key provision of an omnibus budget bill C-4 that passed two years ago. The legislation granted cabinet virtually unchecked powers to limit employees’ right to strike, similar to a 2008 Saskatchewan Act now ruled unlawful.
“I hope the government is taking a look at this decision,” said Robyn Benson, national president of the Public Service Alliance of Canada. “We’re going through it page by page, clause by clause – and so should they, because this clearly shows, in our mind, that the government is going to have some problems.”
Treasury Board president Tony Clement did not comment. “We will be studying the decision carefully,” a spokesperson said. Opposition MP Alexandre Boulerice (Rosemont-La Petite-Patrie, Que.), New Democrat labour critic, described the ruling as “a warning to governments of every level in Canada that would try to trample on this important right.”
Cabinet in 2013 amended the Public Service Labour Relations Act giving itself an “exclusive right to determine whether any service, facility or activity of the Government of Canada is essential because it is or will be necessary for the safety or security of the public or a segment of the public.” The government inserted the amendments on the 232nd page of a 309-page omnibus bill.
Clement said at the time that, while cabinet knew the Supreme Court would rule on the right to strike, “I’m not going to wait”; “I represent a national government,” he told reporters.
The federal bill echoed a Saskatchewan law, the Public Service Essential Services Act, that also allowed Crown agencies, municipalities, universities and other public employers to designate any employee as “essential”, and forbidden from striking. The Supreme Court ruled last Friday the Saskatchewan Act is unconstitutional and must be withdrawn within a year, describing the right to strike as “indispensable” in collective bargaining.
“Up until Bill C-4, we were able to have consultation with employers, and we were able to go to the Public Service Labour Relations Board to argue our case and make some determinations,” said PSAC’s Benson. “This government took that right away. That’s why this win is so very important to us. Mr. Clement doesn’t have the right now to just say who is deemed to be essential.”
Second Loss In Two Weeks
Prof. Eric Tucker of Osgoode Hall described the Supreme Court judgment as a significant benchmark for labour relations. “I don’t think you could have a stronger decision than this one,” Tucker said. “Simply being able to form a union and talk with your employer is not going to be enough, unless you have some bargaining leverage.”
“It’s the right to collectively withdraw labour that provides that leverage,” Tucker said. “That’s what makes collective bargaining meaningful.”
“It clearly doesn’t mean that legislatures cannot limit the right to strike,” Tucker continued. “If they’re going to do that, they need to do it in a way that is minimally impairing.”
Union executives praised the judgment. “It is a phenomenal day,” said Hassan Yussuff, president of the Canadian Labour Congress. “The government needs to take a great deal of care if they’re going to intervene, to interrupt what workers now have under the constitution.”
Debi Daviau, president of the Professional Institute of the Public Service, said the judgment vetoed “carte blanche” cabinet powers limiting the right to strike: “This decision is a direct challenge to this Conservative legislation which has imposed the most radical changes to federal public service labour relations in forty years,” Daviau said.
The ruling was cabinet’s second Supreme Court defeat in two weeks on labour policy. Justices on January 16 struck down a 1920 cabinet ban on RCMP members joining a union.
Share on Facebook